Reusable checklist

Information Verification Checklist

Use this checklist when you encounter an online claim, AI-generated answer, recommendation, statistic, social-media post, article or other information that you may need to rely on.

You do not need to complete every item for every piece of information. The appropriate level of checking depends on the importance of the claim and the consequences of getting it wrong.

Quick rule: The more important the decision, the more carefully you should verify the information behind it.

1. Identify the exact claim

Before searching for evidence, make sure you know exactly what is being claimed.

A vague statement is difficult to verify because it may not be clear what evidence would actually confirm or contradict it.

2. Identify the source

Determine where the information originated rather than relying only on the page or person that repeated it.

A screenshot, repost or social-media summary may be useful as a lead, but it does not necessarily provide enough context to establish the original claim.

3. Check the date

Information can become outdated without becoming obviously false.

A statement that was accurate several years ago may no longer describe the current situation.

4. Check context

Numbers and statements can be misleading when important conditions are omitted.

Ask: “What information would change the meaning of this statement?”

5. Examine the evidence

Look for evidence that directly supports the important part of the claim.

The existence of a citation is not enough. The underlying material should support the specific statement being made.

6. Check numbers and statistics

Statistics can appear authoritative while still being misunderstood or presented without necessary context.

For example, “risk increased by 50%” does not tell you the underlying absolute risk unless the baseline is also known.

7. Watch the language

Pay attention to language that may make a conclusion appear stronger than its evidence.

Strong language is not automatically evidence of an incorrect claim. It simply means that the evidence should support the strength of the conclusion.

8. Compare independent evidence

For consequential information, avoid depending entirely on one source.

Five websites repeating the same press release are not necessarily five independent sources.

9. If AI generated the information

AI-generated answers deserve particular attention because a fluent answer can combine correct information with errors or unsupported details.

For a detailed AI-specific process, see How to Verify an AI Answer.

10. Consider the consequences

Verification should be proportional to the potential impact of an error.

Low consequence

A casual question, hobby fact or minor piece of information may require only a quick sanity check.

Moderate consequence

Important work, purchases or decisions may justify checking the original source and at least one additional reliable source.

High consequence

Health, legal, financial, safety or security decisions deserve authoritative sources and, where appropriate, qualified professional advice.

11. Use Supience as an initial signal

The Supience Information Check can help you examine observable characteristics of a piece of information before deciding where to investigate further.

It can be useful for identifying areas involving:

The result is not a truth score and should not replace the verification steps above.

Keep in mind what the tool does not do: it does not ask follow-up questions, it does not retain a list of past checks, and it does not store the text you submit. Only the most recent result on your device is available for comparison. If you want to refer back to a previous check, copy or share the result before submitting new text.

Run the Supience Information Check

12. Final decision checklist

Before relying on an important claim, ask these final questions:

A compact five-question version

What?

What exactly am I being asked to believe?

Who?

Who produced the original information?

When?

Is the information current and relevant?

Evidence?

What supports the important claim?

And finally: What happens if this information is wrong? Let the potential consequence determine how much verification you need.

Save this checklist

This checklist can be used whenever you encounter information that looks important, surprising or unusually confident. The goal is not to distrust everything. The goal is to match the amount of verification to the importance of the claim.

For more background, read the Supience Guide or learn how the indicator itself works in the Supience Methodology.

Questions about information verification

What should I check before relying on information?

Identify the exact claim, source, date, context and supporting evidence. Then check important numbers, definitions and qualifications and compare the claim with independent evidence where appropriate.

How can I verify a claim quickly?

Start with the single claim that matters most. Find the original source, check when it was produced, determine whether the context matches your situation, and look for direct evidence rather than relying only on repeated summaries.

When should information receive more scrutiny?

Information deserves more careful verification when it could materially affect health, money, safety, legal rights, security, employment or other important decisions.

Where to go next

How to Verify a Source

A practical process for checking whether a source actually supports a claim.

Read the guide →

When a Citation Doesn't Support the Claim

How to check whether a citation actually backs the statement it appears to support.

Read the guide →

How to Tell If a Statistic Is Misleading

Reading percentages, comparisons and averages critically.

Read the guide →

Why Two Studies Can Disagree

Why apparent contradictions in research are normal, and what they mean.

Read the guide →

How to Read a Scientific Abstract

What an abstract tells you, and what it leaves out.

Read the guide →

Logical Fallacies in Viral Posts

Common patterns of reasoning that feel persuasive without supporting a claim.

Read the guide →